Active vs passive investing: the costs you can count before you start — Ouinex Blog cover
Comparisons

Active vs passive investing: the costs you can count before you start

Updated November 2026

Updated November 2026

Active vs passive investing is a choice between trying to beat an index and simply tracking one. The difference you can measure before you put in a single pound is cost: what a fund charges each year, how often it trades and what each trade costs.

This page compares active investing vs passive investing on those numbers only, with one worked example on £10,000. It makes no claim about which approach does better.

What is the difference between active and passive investing?

Passive investing tracks an index and trades only when the index changes. Active investing picks investments to try to beat an index, so it usually trades more and charges more.

The difference you can measure in advance is cost. Active investing relies on ongoing research and regular buying and selling in an attempt to beat an index; passive investing holds for the long term and limits buying and selling. A passive portfolio is close to buy-and-hold by design.

Active investing is not the same as active trading. Active investing means choosing what to hold, usually for months or years. Active trading means opening and closing positions within days or hours, and its costs are counted per trade rather than per year. A separate Tips piece on whether day trading is worth it covers that maths.

If you are still working out which approach fits you, start with finding an investment style that suits you.

Passive vs active investing: the costs side by side

Every row below is a cost, or something that drives a cost, that you can look up before you invest.

Cost item

Passive

Active

What you pay for

Tracking an index

A manager's (or your own) choices about what to hold

Ongoing charge (the yearly fund fee)

Lower

Higher

Portfolio turnover

Low: holdings change when the index changes

Higher: holdings change when the manager's view changes

Dealing costs inside the portfolio

Few trades, so little paid in spreads and commissions

More trades, so more paid in spreads and commissions

UK stamp duty

0.5% on purchases of UK shares, on the few purchases it makes

0.5% on purchases of UK shares, on every purchase

Cash held back

Usually small: the aim is to stay fully invested in the index

Can be larger: cash kept for withdrawals or new ideas

What the result depends on

The index, minus costs

The manager's or investor's choices, minus costs

Three facts sit behind the table. Passive funds typically have lower yearly charges than active ones, and that charge leaves out the fund's own trading costs, which is why turnover matters on its own line. Turnover is the share of a portfolio replaced in a year, and an index fund's is low because it replaces holdings only when the index changes. And in the UK, buying existing shares in a UK company usually carries a 0.5% tax or duty on the transaction.

Worked example: one year of costs on £10,000

Illustrative only. The portfolio is held flat at £10,000 all year, so the example shows costs, never returns. Every rate is an assumption for the arithmetic, not a market average:

  • Ongoing charge: 0.15% passive, 0.75% active.
  • Turnover: 5% passive, 60% active.
  • Dealing cost: 0.25% of the value turned over, covering spreads and commissions on the sale and the replacement purchase. Stamp duty is shown separately.

Line

Passive

Active

Ongoing charge

0.15% × £10,000 = £15.00

0.75% × £10,000 = £75.00

Value turned over

5% = £500

60% = £6,000

Dealing cost at 0.25%

£1.25

£15.00

Total for the year

£16.25 (0.16%)

£90.00 (0.90%)

Ten years at the same flat value

£162.50

£900.00

If the holdings are UK shares: 0.5% stamp duty on purchases

+ £2.50 (year total £18.75)

+ £30.00 (year total £120.00)

On these assumptions the gap is £73.75 a year, or £737.50 over ten years at a flat value, before any stamp duty. Change an assumption and the totals change; the method does not. Take a fund's ongoing charge and turnover from its own documents, multiply, and you have its running cost before you start.

What the cost gap does and does not tell you

The cost gap tells you what each approach charges. It does not tell you what each approach delivers.

The active v passive investing debate is about results after costs, and it is long-running. This page does not settle it and quotes no performance figure. Costs are known in advance; results are not. A higher charge can only be judged against what a manager adds, and that can only be judged afterwards.

Both approaches carry market risk. A passive fund falls when its index falls; an active fund can fall further or less far than its index. Neither protects your capital, and a lower cost is not a promise of a better result.

Active investing, active trading and Ouinex

Ouinex is a trading venue for CFDs and crypto perpetual futures, not a fund platform. On a CFD you speculate on price without owning the asset, and positions are usually held for hours or days rather than years. That is active trading, not active investing, and the costs are counted per trade.

Every trade has a dealing cost. Ouinex charges zero commission on forex, stock indices and commodities: you pay the spread. Stock derivatives are 0.3%; crypto perpetuals are 0.045%. The fees page shows how Ouinex charges per trade.

CFDs and perpetual futures are leveraged products and carry a risk of loss. Leverage amplifies both gains and losses, and dealing costs apply whether a trade wins or loses.

FAQ: active vs passive investing questions answered

What is the difference between active and passive investing?

Passive investing tracks an index and trades only when the index changes. Active investing chooses what to hold in an attempt to beat an index, so it usually trades more often and charges a higher yearly fee. The difference you can measure before you start is cost; the difference in results is only known afterwards.

Is it better to invest in active or passive funds?

There is no single answer, and this page gives no recommendation. Passive funds usually cost less to run. Active funds usually cost more and depend on a manager's choices, which may or may not cover that extra cost. Which suits you depends on the costs you accept, what you expect from a manager and your own circumstances.

Is an index fund passive investing?

Yes. An index fund aims to match its index and changes its holdings only when the index changes, which is what a passive approach means. Index funds and exchange-traded funds that track an index are both passive. How the two differ, in structure, costs and trading hours, is covered in a separate comparison of ETFs and index funds.

What is portfolio turnover?

Turnover is the share of a portfolio's holdings replaced over a year. A fund with 60% turnover has, in effect, sold and replaced 60% of its value in that year. Higher turnover means more dealing, so more spreads, commissions and, on UK shares, stamp duty. Those costs sit outside the yearly ongoing charge.

Conclusion

Active and passive investing differ in philosophy: one tries to beat an index, the other tracks it. They also differ in cost, and cost is the only part you can count before you start.

A passive approach usually means a lower yearly charge and little trading inside the portfolio. An active approach usually means a higher charge and more trading, paid every year whatever the result. On a flat £10,000, the illustrative gap was £73.75 a year. Neither approach removes market risk, and neither cost tells you the result.

Count the cost first, then decide what you expect to get for it. If you trade rather than invest, the same rule applies trade by trade: compare per-trade costs on Ouinex.

Sources

  1. Investopedia: Active vs. Passive Investing: Key Differences and Strategies (updated 6 September 2026)
  2. Investopedia: Understanding Expense Ratios: Calculation, Components, Examples (updated 3 April 2026)
  3. Investopedia: What Is a Turnover Ratio? Definition, Significance, and Analysis (updated 20 September 2026)
  4. GOV.UK: Tax when you buy shares (Stamp Duty and Stamp Duty Reserve Tax)
‹ Back to Ouinex Blog